The overrepresentation of certain ethnic groups or nationalities in crime statistics across four European countries: the Netherlands, Belgium, Germany, and France. It addresses which ethnicities are overrepresented, the reasons behind their involvement in criminal activities, and compares the severity of the issue across these nations.
Ethnic Overrepresentation in Crime Statistics
Netherlands
In the Netherlands, non-Western migrants are significantly overrepresented in crime statistics. Data from 2009 indicates that while 1% of native Dutch individuals were suspected of a crime, this figure rose to 3.8% for non-Western migrants. Among these, Antillean Dutch individuals had the highest suspicion rate at 6.0%, followed by Moroccan Dutch at 5.3%, Surinamese Dutch at 4.1%, and Turkish Dutch at 3.1%. Young males in these groups show even higher rates, with 9.4% of Antillean Dutch males and 8.8% of Moroccan Dutch males suspected of crimes. Arrest rates further confirm this trend, with Moroccans at 34%, Turks and Surinamese at 22-23%, compared to 15% for comparable native Dutch boys. Additionally, over half of Moroccan Dutch males aged 18-24 in Rotterdam have been suspected of crimes by police.
Belgium
In Belgium, individuals without Belgian nationality, who make up 13% of the population, accounted for 28% of criminal convictions in 2020. Notably, 44.54% of the prison population in 2024 did not hold Belgian citizenship. Moroccan men are particularly overrepresented, especially in Brussels, where their share in correctional court cases rose from 8% to 29% between 1976 and 1981. Their recidivism rate is also higher at 50%, compared to 32% for Belgians.
Germany
Germany shows a marked overrepresentation of non-German nationals in crime statistics. In 2023, 31.8% of murder suspects and 34% of sexual offense suspects were non-German, with 75% of human trafficking suspects falling into this category. The number of crimes committed by foreign nationals rose by 17.8% in 2023, reaching a high not seen since 2016. Refugees and asylum seekers are particularly overrepresented, being seven times more likely to be suspects in serious violent crimes than expected based on their population share.
France
In France, systematic data on ethnicity in crime statistics is limited due to legal restrictions on such categorizations. However, a confidential report highlights Afghan migrants as a group with notable involvement in crime, linked to integration issues following significant inflows since 2015. Broader trends in the marginalized banlieues (suburbs) also point to higher crime rates among migrant communities, though specific ethnic breakdowns are scarce.
Reasons for Overrepresentation in Crime
Netherlands
Several factors contribute to the overrepresentation of non-Western migrants in Dutch crime statistics. Socioeconomic disadvantage accounts for 22% of this disparity, with low education, high unemployment, and poverty playing significant roles. Living in urbanized, often disadvantaged neighborhoods explains another 19%. Demographic factors, such as a younger population and a higher proportion of males, also contribute. Family structure issues, particularly among Antillean communities, and weaker social bonds increase the likelihood of delinquent behavior. Cultural dissonance and migration-related stress, alongside potential ethnic profiling by police, further exacerbate the issue, with 46% of the overrepresentation remaining unexplained by behavioral or social factors.
Belgium
In Belgium, socioeconomic marginality is a primary driver for the overrepresentation of Moroccan men in crime statistics, with high unemployment and low education levels correlating with increased criminal involvement. Socialization differences between genders within this community also play a role, as men are more exposed to risk factors. Broader societal vulnerability, including social exclusion, and potential ethnic profiling by police are additional contributors. The socioeconomic status of the country of origin may also influence crime among transient offender groups.
Germany
Socioeconomic challenges, discrimination, and limited access to education are key factors behind the overrepresentation of non-Germans, particularly refugees and asylum seekers, in crime statistics. Integration difficulties, especially among those with uncertain legal status, compound these issues. The rapid influx of migrants since 2015, often from North Africa and Syria, has been linked to an 80% rise in migrant crime between 2014 and 2015. Young male migrants, including unaccompanied minors, are notably involved in petty and violent crimes, often displaying aggression towards authorities. Overwhelmed police forces and social exclusion further perpetuate this cycle.
France
In France, crime among migrant communities, particularly in the banlieues, is driven by socioeconomic exclusion, with high poverty and unemployment rates creating fertile ground for delinquency. Integration challenges, cultural tensions, and a lack of positive role models exacerbate the situation. Specific groups like Afghan migrants face additional barriers due to their status as economic migrants and cultural clashes. Institutional distrust, fueled by incidents of police violence, also contributes to tensions and criminal behavior within these communities.
Comparative Analysis: Severity Across Countries
Comparing the four countries, Germany appears to face the most severe issue of ethnic overrepresentation in crime statistics. The overrepresentation of refugees and asylum seekers, particularly from North Africa and Syria, is stark, with a sevenfold higher likelihood of involvement in serious violent crimes compared to their population share. The 17.8% increase in crimes by foreign nationals in 2023, alongside high-profile incidents like the 2015-2016 New Year’s Eve assaults in Cologne, underscores the scale of the challenge. In contrast, the Netherlands shows significant overrepresentation among Antillean and Moroccan Dutch, but the issue is more contained through socioeconomic explanations. Belgium’s focus on Moroccan men reveals a pronounced but narrower problem, while France’s limited data makes it harder to assess, though Afghan migrants and banlieue dynamics suggest growing concerns.
Conclusion
Ethnic overrepresentation in crime statistics is a multifaceted issue across the Netherlands, Belgium, Germany, and France, driven by socioeconomic disadvantage, integration challenges, demographic factors, and institutional dynamics like potential profiling. While each country faces unique challenges due to differing migration histories and policies, Germany stands out with the most severe overrepresentation, particularly among refugees and asylum seekers. Addressing these disparities requires targeted interventions focusing on socioeconomic inclusion, effective integration policies, and equitable law enforcement practices.
Sources:
- https://ris.utwente.nl/ws/files/6732761/some.pdf
- https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Immigration_and_crime
- https://cris.maastrichtuniversity.nl/en/publications/minority-paradoxes-ethnic-differences-in-self-reported-offending-
- https://pure.eur.nl/ws/portalfiles/portal/48075319/Repub_113611.pdf
- https://repository.wodc.nl/bitstream/handle/20.500.12832/49/ca07-04-summary_tcm28-68433.pdf?sequence=3&isAllowed=y
- https://nltimes.nl/2025/06/20/ethnicity-definitely-plays-role-dutch-criminal-justice-system-study-finds
- https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/07352166.2018.1533379
- https://migrant-integration.ec.europa.eu/sites/default/files/2019-09/shadowreport2018_final-embargoed_12-09-2019.pdf
- https://www.fairtrials.org/app/uploads/2022/06/2022-05-20-evidence_racial_injustice_final.pdf
- https://ocindex.net/country/netherlands/belgium
